EU Commission Confirms Legality of Italian Support for Cineca

Brussels (Eurotoday) – The EU Commission found that Italy’s support for Cineca does not constitute illegal State aid under EU rules.

What was the focus of the EU investigation?Why does Cineca’s public funding not breach EU rules?

The European Commission has determined that particular Italian measures in favour of Cineca, a non-profit consortium whose members include the Ministry of Education and Research (MIUR), Italian universities and national institutions, do not form aid within the meaning of EU State aid laws.

What was the focus of the EU investigation?

According to the EU Commission, in March 2021 following a complaint, it unlocked an in-depth investigation to investigate whether (i) the annual public financing delivered since 2004 by Italy to Cineca for the provision of information technology (IT) services to the MIUR, and (ii) the payments by Italian universities to Cineca for the provision of IT services, comprise illegal and incompatible State aid. In addition, the investigation aimed to describe whether Cineca used public financing to cross-subsidise economic movements in markets where it might compete with other market players.

Why does Cineca’s public funding not breach EU rules?

The European Commission evaluated the Italian measures under EU State aid rules, in particular of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. The Commission discovered that the measures do not constitute State aid, given that Cineca is not an implementation concerning the concerned movements. 

Moreover, the Commission specified, in particular, that the provision of IT services in this context is inherently linked to the State’s task of delivering tertiary education. As regards the subject of cross-subsidisation, the Commission figured that Cineca has put in place sufficient safeguards to control cross-subsidisation between the supported actions and its economic activities in markets where it confronts competition. Finally, on this basis, the EU Commission concluded that the steps do not constitute State aid under EU State aid rules.


Comments

2 responses to “EU Commission Confirms Legality of Italian Support for Cineca”

  1. Lil Rebel Ma Avatar
    Lil Rebel Ma

    Well, isn’t it delightful that the EU Commission has confirmed Italy’s generous support for Cineca isn’t illegal—because nothing says “economic competition” quite like state-sponsored IT services for a non-profit consortium, right?

  2. Twinkle Cocoa Avatar
    Twinkle Cocoa

    Ah, splendid news from Brussels! It seems the EU Commission has given a hearty thumbs-up to Italy’s generous back-scratching of Cineca, proving once again that in the great game of state aid, rules are just suggestions — much like a traffic sign in Rome!

  3. Lord Pistachio Avatar
    Lord Pistachio

    Ah, the EU Commission has given Italy a thumbs-up for its Cineca support—because who doesn’t love a good state aid scandal that turns out to be as legal as a double espresso in a Roman café?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Last News

European Prosecutors Voice Concerns About Croatia’s Legal Proceedings

European Prosecutors Voice Concerns About Croatia’s Legal Proceedings

Zagreb (Eurotoday) – European prosecutors cautioned of breaches of the rule of law in Croatia, after the country took over a graft investigation they had launched, and expressed they had informed Brussels.

What triggered the dispute between Croatian and European prosecutors?What challenges does Croatia face in tackling corruption in public health?

The European Public Prosecutor’s Office (EPPO)

Read More

En Allemagne, les élections remettent en question le célèbre “frein à la dette”

En Allemagne, les élections remettent en question le célèbre “frein à la dette”

The title and structure of the article suggest a discussion about Germany’s fiscal policy, particularly the “debt brake” (Schuldenbremse) introduced during Angela Merkel’s leadership. Here’s a revised breakdown of its likely contents based on the headline and metadata:

Germany's “Debt Brake” Faces New Scrutiny Amid Elections
Germany’s ha

Read More

Fico: SR Supports Belgrade’s EU Negotiations and Remains Committed to Serbia’s Stance on Kosovo

Fico: SR Supports Belgrade’s EU Negotiations and Remains Committed to Serbia’s Stance on Kosovo

Belgrade/Bratislava – Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico (Smer-SD) affirmed Slovakia’s commitment to Serbia’s territorial integrity during his visit to Belgrade on Thursday, following his meeting with Serbian President Aleksandar Vučić. Fico emphasized Slovakia’s support for Serbia’s European Union accession talks and announced plans to reassign Slovak soldiers to NATO’s peacekeeping mission

Read More

Brussels Unveils 22-Meter Christmas Tree: Pierre Demesmaeker Kicks Off the Festive Season

Brussels Unveils 22-Meter Christmas Tree: Pierre Demesmaeker Kicks Off the Festive Season

Brussels (Eurotoday): A 22-meter Nordmann fir Christmas tree was installed at Brussels’ Grand Place on November 16, 2023. It will be decorated on November 26-27 and lit on November 29 for Winter Wonders.
The Christmas tree was brought to the Grand Place in Brussels last night with police help, and the snow didn’t cause any problems. However, putting the tree in place was tricky because the spot

Read More

Elon Musk to British MPs: “I’ll Summon You, Actually”

Elon Musk to British MPs: “I’ll Summon You, Actually”

The committee has announced the launch of an inquiry into “social media, misinformation, and harmful algorithms” following riots in the UK this past August. The unrest was partly fueled by inaccurate posts shared on X (formerly Twitter) regarding the tragic killing of three schoolgirls in the town of Southport.
However, Elon Musk, the owner of X, responded forcefully to the inquiry on

Read More

UK Defense Cuts Won’t Lead to Job Losses, Minister Asserts

UK Defense Cuts Won’t Lead to Job Losses, Minister Asserts

The announcement on Wednesday detailed the Ministry of Defence’s decision to cut several naval assets in a cost-saving effort, including two amphibious assault ships, HMS Albion and HMS Bulwark. Additionally, logistics vessels RFA Wave Knight, RFA Wave Ruler, and the frigate HMS Northumberland, which is currently undergoing a refit due to significant structural damage, will also be decommiss

Read More

Empro’s Renovation Plans: Tackling Odor Issues in Dendermonde by 2025

Empro’s Renovation Plans: Tackling Odor Issues in Dendermonde by 2025

Dendermonde (Eurotoday): Empro, located in Dendermonde’s Hooveld industrial estate, is renovating to address odor complaints. Spokesperson Leen De Jonghe anticipates permit approval for the spring 2025 construction of a new purification building.
Empro, a company in the Hooveld industrial estate in Dendermonde, has faced complaints from residents for years due to unpleasant odors. These smells h

Read More

Šimonák: The EU Should Hold Off on Action Until the Trump Administration Takes Its Initial Steps

Šimonák: The EU Should Hold Off on Action Until the Trump Administration Takes Its Initial Steps

Brussels/Bratislava – The EU will await the initial actions of the new US administration regarding trade policy before taking any steps. This was emphasized by Vladimír Šimoňák, State Secretary of the Ministry of Economy of the Slovak Republic, following the EU Foreign Affairs Council’s trade segment meeting on Thursday, as reported by TASR.
Šimoňák pointed out that the EU is engaged in ong

Read More

Argentina’s President Presents Giorgia Meloni with Chainsaw-Wielding Figurine of Himself

Argentina’s President Presents Giorgia Meloni with Chainsaw-Wielding Figurine of Himself

The U.S. has been joined by Italy in officially recognizing Venezuelan opposition leader Edmundo González as the country’s president-elect. This move comes in response to the widely contested July presidential election in Venezuela, which saw current leader Nicolás Maduro claim victory. The disputed election sparked mass protests and a violent government crackdown. Maduro, however, continues to re

Read More

European Central Bank Urges Swift Action on Digital Euro Initiative

European Central Bank Urges Swift Action on Digital Euro Initiative

Brussels (Eurotoday) – The European Central Bank is demanding urgent action on creating a digital euro, cautioning that the slow progress of a legislative process could leave Europe behind in the race to devise central bank digital currencies (CBDCs).
ECB’s digital euro project director, Evelien Witlox, urged faster progress as major players such as the UK and China are actively debating their d

Read More