The incident marks a significant setback for Keir Starmer, who has pledged to rebuild public trust in politics. Starmer will be hoping that Louise Haigh’s rapid and dramatic resignation sends a clear signal to voters that the newly-elected Labour government is serious about upholding high standards in public life.
However, the opposition Conservative Party has been quick to capitalize on the situation, using it to criticize Starmer’s leadership. “Louise Haigh has made the right decision by stepping down. It is evident she failed to meet the standards expected of a Member of Parliament,” a Conservative Party spokesperson said in a statement.
The spokesperson also called into question Starmer’s judgment in appointing Haigh to a Cabinet role overseeing a £30 billion budget, despite knowing about her prior fraud conviction. “The fact that Keir Starmer was already aware of this conviction raises serious questions. Why did the Prime Minister still place Ms Haigh in such a pivotal role? It is now on Keir Starmer to explain this clear lapse in judgment to the British public,” the Conservative statement continued.
The controversy dates back to Haigh’s mid-20s, when she worked as a public policy manager at Aviva, a major insurance company. At the time, Haigh reported to police that her belongings, including her work phone, had been stolen, and she was subsequently issued a replacement device. Later, she rediscovered the original phone at home, reportedly in a drawer, and turned it on—an action she admitted had “triggered police attention.”
In her resignation letter, Haigh acknowledged her error, stating, “I should have immediately informed my employer, and not doing so straight away was a mistake.” She also expressed regret about following her solicitor’s advice not to comment during the police inquiry. She ultimately pleaded guilty at Camberwell Green Magistrates Court and received what she described as the “lowest possible outcome,” a discharge.
The news has opened the door for further political attacks on Starmer’s leadership, as questions linger over his decision-making process during Haigh’s Cabinet appointment.
Reporting contributions by Tim Ross and Zoya Sheftalovich.
Leave a Reply