In his analysis of baptism, Hieromartyr Hilarion (Troitsky) examines Optatus’s stance on the validity of schismatic baptism. Optatus links baptism closely with the Holy Trinity, compelling him to accept the validity of baptisms in schismatic groups, which aligns with the prevailing Church norms. He agrees with his opponent on the Church’s unity as the bride of Christ but distinguishes between heretics and schismatics. Heretics, he argues, forsake the truth and alter the faith’s symbol; thus, their sacraments, including baptism, are void. Schismatics, though outside the universal Church, share much with it, including faith, so their sacraments cannot be invalidated.
Optatus, in his lenient treatment of Donatists, calls Parmenian a brother, invoking Isaiah to maintain fraternal ties despite discord. Despite not being fully detached from the Church, the Donatists form a separate Catholic entity but only in semblance, as Optatus insists they are outside the Church. Schism is a severe sin akin to betrayal and is distressing to God; schismatics lack the full unity the Church embodies.
Optatus’s reasoning contains inconsistencies, particularly regarding schismatics’ position relative to the Church and the efficacy of sacraments in schismatic communities. These issues are later addressed by St. Augustine, who emphasizes the Church’s universality as a hallmark of its truth, contrasting the limited scope of the Donatists. Augustine, a primary opponent of Donatism, contends that the Church must be global, fulfilling biblical prophecies and Christ’s directive to spread the Gospel worldwide.
Augustine’s writings refute Donatist exclusivity, asserting the real Church’s catholicity and its inclusive nature. Tichonius, a Donatist who adopted a more orthodox view of the Church’s sanctity, faced censure from his peers. He viewed the Church as comprising both good and bad elements, akin to biblical symbols. Augustine diverges from the Donatists by accepting that the Church inevitably includes sinners, as seen in biblical parables and teachings.
Augustine’s conception allows for the coexistence of virtue and sin within the Church, maintaining unity without disrupting discipline. He insists on corrective measures grounded in love and fraternity, rather than punitive excommunication. Unity and charity, Augustine argues, are essential, even when dealing with sinners, emphasizing internal reform over schism. In these discussions, the earthly state of the Church, its universal mission, and its composite nature are central themes, tackled extensively by Augustine against Donatist claims.
Leave a Reply