Switzerland’s stunning Alpine lakes hold a perilous secret beneath their serene surfaces—thousands of tons of discarded ammunition. For decades, the Swiss military used these lakes as dumping grounds for obsolete and surplus stockpiles, and now the country is grappling with the overwhelming challenge of removing them safely.
In a bid to tackle this issue, Switzerland’s Federal Ministry of Defense, Civil Protection, and Sport has launched an innovative competition, offering a prize of 50,000 Swiss francs for viable solutions. Participants have until February 2025 to submit their proposals, with winners scheduled to be announced in April of the same year.
Hidden Dangers Beneath the Surface
Numerous Swiss lakes remain impacted by this legacy of dumping. For instance, Lake Lucerne is estimated to contain around 3,300 tonnes of ammunition, while Lake Neuchâtel harbors approximately 4,500 tonnes. Other affected bodies of water include lakes Thun and Brienz, with munitions dumped between 1918 and 1967.
The discarded ammunition spans various types, including unstable or surplus stocks and decommissioned production batches. Much of it lies at depths ranging from 150 to 220 meters, though the debris in Lake Neuchâtel is closer to the surface, at depths of just 6 to 7 meters.
The Risks and the Challenges
These underwater stockpiles pose significant hazards. Despite being submerged, the risk of explosion remains, as many munitions still contain live explosives. Additionally, concerns over environmental contamination loom large, with toxic substances such as TNT potentially leaching into the ecosystem, polluting both water and soil.
Removing these munitions presents an array of technical challenges. Poor underwater visibility, the varying sizes and weights of the objects, and their magnetic properties complicate retrieval efforts. Disturbing the layers of sediment that cover the ammunition risks further ecological damage, as it could deplete the low oxygen levels required to sustain these fragile lake habitats.
How Did We Get Here?
The practice of dumping munitions into lakes was once considered an acceptable disposal method. For decades, geologists assured the Swiss military that this approach posed minimal risk. However, modern reassessments have revealed the potentially dire consequences of this outdated practice.
Switzerland’s policy of armed neutrality, which necessitates maintaining a large militia, contributed to the stockpiling of surplus munitions. Limited land area and a dense population made it challenging to establish suitable disposal sites, leading the military to use lakes as a convenient alternative.
Past Explosions and Rising Awareness
While no incidents have yet been directly linked to lake-dumped munitions, Switzerland has experienced other explosive catastrophes. In 1947, a deadly explosion at an underground ammunition depot in the village of Mitholz killed nine people and left the area devastated.
The aftermath of that tragedy, alongside the discovery of unexploded munitions emerging from retreating glaciers, has heightened awareness of these latent dangers. This growing concern has galvanized the government to prioritize innovative solutions for the safe removal of dumped munitions.
A Call for Innovation
Acknowledging the risks associated with traditional remediation techniques, the Swiss government aims to uncover groundbreaking approaches through this competition. The goal is to find methods that can safely extract the munitions while minimizing harm to aquatic ecosystems.
Although winning proposals might not be implemented immediately, they could pave the way for further research and technological advancements. Switzerland is also seeking advice from countries like the United Kingdom, Norway, and Denmark, which have extensive experience managing underwater munitions from World War II.
The Path Forward
This initiative symbolizes Switzerland’s commitment to addressing the hidden environmental and safety risks lurking beneath its idyllic lakes. By turning to global expertise and fostering innovation, the nation hopes to chart a sustainable path toward resolving this decades-old issue, ensuring the continued preservation of its pristine natural landscapes.
Illustrative Photo by Louis: https://www.pexels.com/photo/white-and-red-flag-on-boat-2068480/
Leave a Reply