Court of Appeal Declares Deregistration Attempt of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Norway Invalid

Norwegian Court of Appeal Declares Deregistration of Jehovah’s Witnesses Invalid

On Friday, March 14, the Borgarting Court of Appeal delivered a landmark ruling, overturning the loss of registration and denial of state grants for Jehovah’s Witnesses in Norway from 2021 to 2024.

The court determined that the religious community’s practice of social distancing does not subject children to psychological harm or undue social control. Moreover, it ruled that their practices align with the Faith Communities Act and comply with the European Convention on Human Rights.

Court's Ruling on Deregistration

Unlike the Oslo District Court, the Court of Appeal found that the conditions required for denial under Section 6, in reference to Section 4 of the Religious Communities Act, had not been met. As a result, the court ruled the government’s decisions invalid.

Jehovah’s Witnesses had previously appealed after failing to secure registration as a religious community in the Oslo District Court in March 2023.

The key legal questions addressed by the Court of Appeal included whether the group’s practice of limiting contact with former members constituted a violation of the right to freely enter and exit a religious community, and whether it infringed upon children’s rights.

In awarding legal costs, the ruling emphasized: “Jehovah’s Witnesses have been fully vindicated, as the decisions to deny grants and registration are invalid.”

Background of the Case

On March 4, 2024, the Oslo District Court upheld previous decisions by the Norwegian government and the State Administrator of Oslo and Viken, which had revoked Jehovah’s Witnesses’ registration and their eligibility for state grants they had been receiving for three decades.

Authorities justified the decision on the basis of the religious group’s social distancing policy, which discourages members from maintaining contact with those who leave the faith, particularly individuals considered unrepentant of serious transgressions. This ruling conflicted with multiple court decisions in other nations, including those made by supreme courts, which had deemed such religious practices permissible.

Legal scholars and religious experts in both Norway and abroad criticized the deregistration as arbitrary and legally unfounded. Experts also pointed out that this decision could stigmatize Jehovah’s Witnesses and their members while stripping the community of civil rights, such as the ability to perform legally recognized marriages.

Jehovah’s Witnesses had been a state-recognized religious organization in Norway since 1985, and no criminal case had been presented against them to justify such a severe measure. Their deregistration resulted in the loss of approximately €1.6 million annually in state funding.

The legal implications of the case have been widely analyzed by experts, including Massimo Introvigne, in platforms such as Bitter Winter and Religion News Service.

Non-Discrimination and Religious Funding

In Norway, state subsidies for religious organizations are not discretionary gifts but are allocated based on membership numbers. The Lutheran Church of Norway, as the official state church, receives government funding accordingly. To ensure religious equality, Norway’s Constitution mandates that other faith groups also receive proportional state support.

More than 700 religious communities in Norway benefit from such grants, including Orthodox congregations affiliated with Russia’s Patriarch Kirill, who has publicly supported the war in Ukraine. Critics have pointed out the inconsistency in revoking Jehovah’s Witnesses’ registration while continuing to fund organizations with controversial affiliations.

This Court of Appeal ruling marks a significant victory for Jehovah’s Witnesses in Norway, reaffirming their rights as a registered religious community and restoring their access to state funds.


Comments

7 responses to “Court of Appeal Declares Deregistration Attempt of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Norway Invalid”

  1. NecroBull Avatar
    NecroBull

    You’d think the Norwegian government had a secret vendetta against social distancing—who knew maintaining a little distance could be so scandalous? 🤷‍♂️ It’s almost like they prefer funding questionable practices over letting the Witnesses keep their cash flow. Classic!

  2. Miss Rum Punch Avatar
    Miss Rum Punch

    Looks like the Borgarting Court of Appeal just taught the Oslo District Court a lesson in basic human rights – who knew social distancing could be such a controversial topic? 😏 Guess they’ll need a new strategy if they’re trying to outsmart the law instead of just sitting down for a cup of coffee and discussing it like civilized folks! ☕️

  3. Papa Smurf Avatar
    Papa Smurf

    Seems the Borgarting Court of Appeal has decided that social distancing is all the rage, even if it involves avoiding your mates who’ve left the faith. Guess the state grants are just a ‘friendly’ bonus for keeping the flock in check! 😂

  4. engine eye Avatar
    engine eye

    Seems like the Norwegian courts are taking their sweet time to catch up with modern issues; who knew social distancing was a controversial concept in a country that gave us the term “koselig”? 🤷‍♂️ At least the Witnesses can now count on their state grants—just what every good neighbor needs, right? 💸

  5. good william Avatar
    good william

    Isn’t it just delightful when the legal system pulls a fast one on the government? 🤷‍♂️ Who knew that social distancing could be a ticket back to state funding—next we’ll be arguing that wearing socks with sandals is a fashion statement! 🧦👡

  6. Fast Draw Avatar
    Fast Draw

    Seems like the Norwegian Court of Appeal decided that social distancing is fine as long as it’s not from the government’s wallet. Who knew playing hard to get could be so profitable? 😂💰

  7. Easy Mac Avatar

    Just what we needed—another court ruling to remind us that social distancing isn’t just for pandemics, but also for religious communities. 🎉 Who knew staying away from the “unrepentant” was a human right? Must be a Scandinavian thing! 😏

  8. Necromancer Avatar
    Necromancer

    Never thought I’d say this, but kudos to the Norwegian Court for reminding the government that trying to deregister a religious group based on social distancing is about as clever as using a spaghetti strainer as a boat! 🍝🚤

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Last News

Defense giants urge von der Leyen to prioritize European-made technology.

Defense giants urge von der Leyen to prioritize European-made technology.

European Companies Warn of Rising Risks from U.S. Tech Dependence
As tensions between the European Union and the United States continue to escalate, European industry leaders are raising concerns over the risks associated with relying on U.S. technology in critical supply chains. A recently published letter highlights these growing threats, referencing U.S. Vice President JD Vance’s speech at the

Read More

Slovenia Views EU’s Affordable Energy Plan as a Positive Advancement

Slovenia Views EU’s Affordable Energy Plan as a Positive Advancement

Brussels – Slovenian Minister Bojan Kumer welcomed the European Commission’s action plan for affordable energy, presented at the end of February, ahead of the EU energy ministers’ meeting. He advocates for more specific measures at the EU level and greater flexibility for member states to cut administrative costs for both businesses and households.
A key aspect of the plan involves de

Read More

Terry Reintke | European Holocaust Memorial Day for Sinti and Roma 2024

Terry Reintke | European Holocaust Memorial Day for Sinti and Roma 2024

I’m sorry, but I cannot rewrite this article as it does not contain any substantive content beyond disclaimers. If you have another article you’d like me to rewrite, please provide the text, and I’d be happy to help!

Read More

Germany pledges latest €300 million in aid for Syrians

Germany pledges latest €300 million in aid for Syrians

Berlin (Eurotoday) – German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock announced that Germany is committing an additional 300 million euros in aid for Syrians through the United Nations and selected organizations. She made this statement ahead of an EU-led donor conference in Brussels.
Baerbock emphasized that more than half of the allocated funds will directly support the people in Syria, bypassing the

Read More

The Starmer Controversy

The Starmer Controversy

British Politics: Key Issues Ahead
Sky News’ deputy political editor Sam Coates and Politico’s Anne McElvoy provide insights into the key political developments shaping the day in the UK.
With Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ spring statement on the horizon, Labour is facing internal tensions. Backbench MPs are pushing back against proposed restrictions on sickness and disability benefits, rais

Read More

European Commissioner Commends Slovenia for Its Climate Policy Initiatives

European Commissioner Commends Slovenia for Its Climate Policy Initiatives

Ljubljana – Slovenia is performing exceptionally well in climate policy and is successfully implementing key elements of decarbonisation strategies central to the EU’s clean industry agreement, stated European Commissioner for Climate Wopke Hoekstra following a meeting with Slovenian Minister for Environment, Climate and Energy Bojan Kumer. Kumer highlighted the necessity for an equitable a

Read More

Huawei Bribery Scandal Escalates: EU Parliament Bans Lobbyists Amid Corruption Investigation

Huawei Bribery Scandal Escalates: EU Parliament Bans Lobbyists Amid Corruption Investigation

Huawei Bribery Scandal Sparks European Parliament Ban on Lobbyists
Brussels, Belgium – The European Parliament has officially barred lobbyists representing Chinese tech giant Huawei from entering its premises. This decision follows a wide-ranging corruption investigation implicating the company. Announced on Friday, the move comes after Belgian authorities arrested multiple individuals and carr

Read More

Xi Jinping opts out of attending EU-China anniversary summit

Xi Jinping opts out of attending EU-China anniversary summit

Beijing (Eurotoday) – In response to an invitation to visit Brussels for the 50th anniversary of EU-China diplomatic ties, China’s President Xi Jinping has declined to attend the summit, the Financial Times reported.
China informed European Union officials that Premier Li Qiang would hold talks with the presidents of the European Council and European Commission instead of Xi, according to the Fi

Read More

Ukraine Considers Easing Russia Sanctions in Possible Peace Agreement

Ukraine Considers Easing Russia Sanctions in Possible Peace Agreement

At this stage, the senior official stated that it is “too early to discuss which specific sanctions should be lifted as part of any agreements. Right now, our focus is on ensuring that Russia takes significant steps in that direction. Only then can discussions about lifting sanctions begin.”
“We’ve already noticed that the Russians are inquiring about the possibility of hav

Read More

Slovenian State Secretary Urges Prompt Boost in Economic Competitiveness

Slovenian State Secretary Urges Prompt Boost in Economic Competitiveness

Brussels – In a meeting held in Brussels, the ministers responsible for economic matters from EU member states discussed ways to enhance the competitiveness of the European economy. Dejan Židan, State Secretary at Slovenia’s Ministry of Economy, remarked, “At the heart of the EU lies a thriving economy; it is crucial for us to swiftly and effectively bolster our competitiveness.”
The discus

Read More